GlobalHealthAfrica

Posts Tagged ‘West Africa’

West African Healthcare: Problems and Solutions 2

In Health Policies on June 11, 2013 at 10:33 pm

In Part 1, Guest Blogger Udo Obiechefu discussed three major obstacles that West African nations face in their effort to provide accessible quality care for their citizens. In Part 2, Udo explores three solutions that could possibly gain traction as viable options to increase access to care.  

THE SOLUTIONS

Involving the Private Sector: It can be done!

The availability of private health insurance in West Africa is quite limited. Many health insurance plans are only available and marketed to the wealthy and/or expatriate communities. As mentioned in part one, it is apparent that West Africans are willing and able to pay for reasonably priced prepaid services. There is great potential to improve healthcare access and delivery through the availability of well-priced, quality health insurance. CorporateTraining What would make the idea of purchasing health coverage more palatable for citizens of West African nations are more reliable health services. Even if given reasonable choices for coverage, there still has to be confidence in the system to provide the care required. The system can be improved if more is done with the resources available. Some of these resources include the user fees that consumers must pay out of pocket and international aid. The idea of providing private health insurance to low income Africans is already being put to practice. The Health Insurance Fund (HIF) is a foundation devoted to achieving this goal. Through the foundation, donor funds and international monetary aid are linked to health maintenance organizations and insurance companies. These organizations are responsible for the execution of the insurance plans. The mission of the Health Insurance Fund is to protect the wealth of low income African families by utilizing private insurance as a means to access quality care. The resources of the HIF are used to upgrade the medical and administrative services of the contracted insurers and providers. The first HIF program was initiated in Nigeria utilizing Hygeia, which is the largest healthcare service group in the country. At this point in time the HIF has over 120,000 enrollees.  

Community Based Prepayment: Community Solutions for a Continental Problem 

Community based initiatives have the potential to be very effective tools for change. A community based concept that has gained traction in recent years within some ECOWAS nations are Community Based Health Insurance schemes (CBHI). These plans are more accessible than the formal private sector insurance plans currently available to West Africans. Prepayment plans are funded by annual or regular payments. They require reduced fees at the time health services are rendered. Most CBHI schemes involve either hospitalization services or primary care visits. Johannes P. Jutting, in an article analyzing community plans in the Thies region of Western Senegal, came to the conclusion that CBHI plans have the capability of having a strong impact;

“It was shown that in an area where most people are deprived of access to health care of good quality, the introduction of CBHI schemes can make a substantial difference” (Jutting 2003) Community Community based plans are a common sense approach that provides consumers with more realistic financial options. The availability of flexible payments insures a consumer’s ability to make payments that make sense given their financial circumstances. Community based plans also offer the capacity for providers to create community specific options. A group of plans available in Sikasso, Mali may not be the same as plans available in Taoudenni, Mali. The customizations that are made to payment plans in different communities can be based on demographics, disease prevalence and average income of those living in the geographic area. This flexibility allows for high degrees of adaptation between marketplaces. The success of community based initiatives are not a guarantee. Although it has the potential to provide access to care for large majorities of lower income populations, it still is a concept that struggles to include extreme cases of poverty. There is still much research to be done, but the future is promising. Systems that identify community needs and embrace an approach specific to the region have the potential to produce a more sustainable marketplace for middle and working class West Africans to purchase reliable health coverage.

Natural Resources: Where Are the Revenues Going?

Over the last ten years many West African nations and Africa as a continent has seen substantial growth as the result of increased exploitation of African natural resources. From diamonds in Botswana to oil off the coast of Nigeria, Africa offers a vast array of resources that contribute to the foundation on which most of western society sits. What has become evident during this recent increase in West African economic activity is a severe lack in transparency in relation to the taxation practices that seem to be attracting foreign investors. Liberia’s President, Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, believes that African nations are suffering due to lack of appropriate taxation methods;

“Africa, like the rest of the world, is suffering tremendous losses from the illicit and unwarranted outflow of wealth through tax avoidance, shell companies, tax havens, transfer pricing and others, that in a way leads them to avoid their fair share of taxes,” natural resources What should be a vast economic windfall for West African nations and citizens seems to never have a tangible financial impact on the countries from which these resources are being acquired. The 2013 Africa Progress Report concluded that Africa is at a critical point in time where greater investment of natural resource revenue needs to be invested into West African economies. Corruption is a real problem with real economic impacts on West Africans , but a greater issue is the belief of West African governments that an increase in transparency, coupled with stronger negotiations could lead to a loss of business. These ideas must be overcome to gain maximum value and increased revenues for West African. An increased stream of income from ECOWAS nation’s reserves of natural resources could in turn provide the financial ability to improve many of the access to care issues we discussed in part one of this story.

Conclusion

The struggles surrounding health care on the African continent have been well documented. West Africa is no different. For there to be sustainable change within the region the paradigm must be shifted. West African nations must rely more on the ingenuity and resourcefulness of the populations they are seeking to help. Community based solutions offer promising results that involve an approach specific to the region.  ECOWAS nations also must look to maximize their potential by increasing transparency and implementing better business practices. Better utilization of already existing sources of revenue will lead to a greater financial freedom. This increase in financial maturity can provide West African governments with the confidence to take many problems in their healthcare delivery systems head on. Improving the access and delivery of care in West Africa is a daunting task. Lack of funding, a small workforce, poor organization, and a dearth of viable private sector solutions has left many nations in dire situations. Although the current environment is not ideal, the future is not completely bleak. With proper investment of aid, a change in approach and an aggressive and forward thinking collection of decision makers West Africa has the opportunity to improve the access and delivery of health services for millions in the years to come. References

Advertisements

West African Healthcare: Problems and Solutions

In Health Policies, Healthcare on May 11, 2013 at 5:43 pm

In this post, Guest Blogger Udo Obiechefu attempts to start a conversation on some of the issues impacting access and availability of care in West Africa. In his next post, Udo will explore avenues for solving these issues. Enjoy!udo picture

The issues related to health care delivery and access in West Africa is plentiful. Lack of adequate funding, a small workforce, poor organization, and a dearth of viable private sector solutions are just a few of the many dilemmas preventing countless West Africans from attaining sustainable access to quality care. Discussions addressing these issues are numerous and ongoing. I will attempt to contribute the discussion by starting a conversation revolving around three major dilemmas facing West African healthcare. In part two we will discuss possible solutions.

Part 1: The Problems

The Private Sector: Is Private Health Insurance Realistic?

A problem that is evident within the realm of West African healthcare is the lack of an adequate, cost appropriate private sector market. Much of this is due to the fear of high costs and conjecture surrounding the profit motives of potential investors. Although these suspicions may be warranted due to the insurance industries checkered history in other parts of the world, it is important to acknowledge the lack of strong private sector options as another problem plaguing healthcare access in West Africa.  Because of the high out of pocket expenses encumbered by those seeking medical services, healthcare providers have difficulty predicting the flow of revenue. This lack of predictability has lead to the inability of providers to improve the quality of services. As a result of this and many other factors the private sector has remained underutilized.

The reality is that West Africans have proven capable of and willing to prepay for services. This is evident in the success of prepaid cellular cards. Of course, the healthcare market has many complexities and comparisons with the mobile telecommunications market can be a stretch, but what is evident is the basic premise of prepayment is not a foreign idea. The problem resides in the fact that consistent access to quality medical care can be difficult to come by. Questions must be asked about how private insurance can better provide realistic options for citizens of West Africa. What options are available for middle income West Africans? Can the private sector play a role for those living in poverty? More work has to be done in researching all possible avenues for improving the health of West Africans. At this point in time the lack of a competitive private health insurance market has to be viewed as a deficiency.

Staffing: Understaffed, Overworked and Unemployed                                                                

The World Health Organization recommends, as a minimum standard, one physician for every 5,000 inhabitants of a geographic area. Many West African nations fall far short of this criteria. Burkina Faso, Benin, Senegal, Sierra Leon, Niger and Mali all average less than ten physicians per 100,000 inhabitants. This staffing crisis is also present in nursing and hospital administration. Despite the fact that Africa, as a continent, accounts for over 40% of the worlds communicable diseases, it comprises less than five percent of the global health workforce. Unfortunately West African nations are not producing healthcare workers at the rate of demand. Also troubling is the fact that many of the healthcare workers who are available are located in larger cities which leaves those in rural areas an additional burden.

Notwithstanding the issue of shortage, there is also the issue of funding. There are many nurses and midwives who are underemployed or unemployed in West Africa. This is due to nations lacking the financial ability to meet even modest salary demands. This has caused many capable medical professionals to leave the region in hope of finding more opportunity elsewhere. West Africa is being devastated by a “brain drain”. Due to economic, social, and personal reasons well educated, qualified and motivated healthcare professionals in West Africa are seeking opportunities in the west. Europe and North America are reaping the rewards of West African educated healthcare professionals. These issues have lead to an over reliance of many *ECOWAS governments on skeleton staffing or temporary foreign health workers. This dependency has produced a system where instead of making systemic changes to the current healthcare structure that would aid in the production and maintenance of a larger workforce, there is a culture of anticipation and need for the next available foreign assistance to provide relief to a poorly functioning arrangement.

Healthcare Financing: “…..Or lack thereof”

Donor funding accounts for 25% of healthcare financing in one third of African nations. This statistic also holds true for numerous ECOWAS nations. Many foreign funding sources that contribute large amounts of aid to West African countries operate cyclically and can at times cut funding without the host country being prepared to absorb the financial impact. Even more concerning is the high percentage of funding that comes from out of pocket expenses. Sixty percent of health expenses are paid for out of pocket in Africa. These expenses can come in the form of user fees at public facilities, direct payments to private providers and even cash payments to traditional healers.

Numerous West African nations struggle with developing revenue streams to finance their healthcare systems. User fees are currently a source of revenue for West African governments. Although many primary care services are exempt from fees (immunizations, family planning, treatment of communicable disease), it still has proven a burden to care for many poor families. User fees have shown to be largely unpopular and many ECOWAS nations are currently exploring their abolishment. With the abolishment of fees comes the need to find a suitable source of additional revenue which can be quite difficult for low income nations.

References 

Check Back for Part 2……